2016 Golden Desert PF Final: Oakwood BG vs Harker JR
Videos
Shared
Debate
Practice vs AI
Research
settings
Videos
Shared
Debate
Practice vs AI
Research
settings
Videos
Shared
Debate
Practice vs AI
Research
settings

Videos

  • All Videos

  • Lectures

  • NDT

    College Team Debate

  • CX

    HS Team Debate

  • LD

    HS Individual Debate

  • PF

    HS Public Forum

  • Greatest of All-Time

  • My Favorites

  • Watch History

Research

  • Research Workspace
  • Card Search
  • Team Research
  • Practice vs AI
  • Prep Workspace

Coaching

  • Tournaments
  • Team Rankings
  • Coach Workspace
  • News & Forums

Insights

  • Debater Level
  • Topics & Video Statistics
  • Prediction Markets
  • Rules & Glossary
  • Laptop-less Debating
  • All Features

Docs

  • All Videos

  • College Team Debate

    College Team Debate

  • HS Team Debate

    HS Team Debate

  • HS Public Forum

    HS Public Forum

  • HS Individual Debate

    HS Individual Debate

  • Lectures

    Lectures

  • Watch History

  • Greatest of All-Time

    Greatest of All-Time

  • My Favorites

    My Favorites

Research

Coaching

Insights

DocsGitHubGithubSupportAboutPrivacyRedditReddit
Video library
'16
🏆FinalPF

2016 Golden Desert PF Final: Oakwood BG vs Harker JR

Oakwood BG vs Harker JR Golden Desert Finals

Mar 7, 20160.7k

Oakwood is pro while Harker is con. Oakwood wins 3-0.

Comments

Loading comments…

Con Constructive

Negative

  • Tax Revenue Advantages — carbon tax harder to evade (prices easily monitored), less economic distortion than income/sales taxes, shrinks informal economy
  • Tax Revenue Implications × 4 — Harvey: BC revenue used for sales-tax breaks (helps poor); Roberts: Alberta issued annual rebates raising low/mid incomes; Roberts: Alberta funded green subsidies; Roberts: output subsidies discouraged leakage
  • DA — Higher Prices Reduce Demand — Meltzer (Energy Law Journal): carbon tax raises price of carbon-intensive goods, reducing consumer demand and shifting production
  • DA — Green Tech Innovation — Paulo/CIRA: env. policy induces innovation; Freed (UC): ships innovation lowered green-energy price 20% long-run, raised green-to-fossil ratio 11–12.9%, growing past 2030
  • DA — Setting an Example — Cooper: US decarbonization strengthens negotiators' hand; Perman (Maryland): poor nations cite US inaction to delay mitigation
  • Impact — Climate Change / Poverty — NOAA: 2042 point of no return; Palotti (World Bank): warming raises food prices, hurts poorest; Carnegie (World Bank): poor least able to adapt; 100M pushed into poverty by 2030
  • Impact — Emissions-Related Health — Hobbs: +1,000 US deaths per 1°C increase; Garasi: 5% emission reduction → 4.5% mortality reduction

Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 — check it against the video before relying on it.

Related videos

R6Grapevine · PF Videos

Redeem your promo code after creating an account at debateit.tech, full 1-month "All" access to updated card searching, collaborative flowing, and more! Nueva DY debates 1st on the Affirmative, while Plano West HL debates 2nd on the Negative. Before opening the description and viewing the results, we recommend flowing the round yourself and coming up with your own decision. Resolved: The United States federal government should enact a moratorium on hyperscale data center construction. 0:00 - Pre-Round 0:34 - Aff Constructive 5:12 - Neg Constructive 9:40 - 1st Cross 14:28 - Aff Rebuttal 19:45 - Neg Rebuttal 24:33 - 2nd Cross 30:26 - Aff Summary 36:33 - Neg Summary 40:43 - Grand Cross 43:55 - Aff Final 46:26 - Neg Final Nueva (PRO) picks up (Herrig) If you have any recordings you'd like to have uploaded, please email us at pfvideosyt@gmail.com. All proceeds are donated to the Urban Debate League (UDL).

Sep 22, 20261.2k
SemisNSDA · PF Videos

Lincoln Sudbury debates 1st on the Affirmative, while Palm Harbor ML debates 2nd on the Negative. Before opening the description and viewing the results, we recommend flowing the round yourself and coming up with your own decision. Palm Harbor (NEG) Wins on a 6-1 (Albert, Alonso, Binyaminov*, Chong, Holguin, Samara-Reuter, Xu) If you have any recordings you'd like to have uploaded, please email us at pfvideosyt@gmail.com. All proceeds are donated to the Urban Debate League (UDL). Shoutout to Keerat for the recording!

Jul 27, 20265.1k

Queue

Nothing queued. Add a related video with itsbutton and it lines up here, to play when this one ends.