2024 NDT 24 College Semis: Michigan PD (#1) vs Emory KR (#2)
Videos
Shared
Debate
Practice vs AI
Research
settings
Videos
Shared
Debate
Practice vs AI
Research
settings
Videos
Shared
Debate
Practice vs AI
Research
settings

Videos

  • All Videos

  • Lectures

  • NDT

    College Team Debate

  • CX

    HS Team Debate

  • LD

    HS Individual Debate

  • PF

    HS Public Forum

  • Greatest of All-Time

  • My Favorites

  • Watch History

Research

  • Research Workspace
  • Card Search
  • Team Research
  • Practice vs AI
  • Prep Workspace

Coaching

  • Tournaments
  • Team Rankings
  • Coach Workspace
  • News & Forums

Insights

  • Debater Level
  • Topics & Video Statistics
  • Prediction Markets
  • Rules & Glossary
  • Laptop-less Debating
  • All Features

Docs

  • All Videos

  • College Team Debate

    College Team Debate

  • HS Team Debate

    HS Team Debate

  • HS Public Forum

    HS Public Forum

  • HS Individual Debate

    HS Individual Debate

  • Lectures

    Lectures

  • Watch History

  • Greatest of All-Time

    Greatest of All-Time

  • My Favorites

    My Favorites

Research

Coaching

Insights

DocsGitHubGithubSupportAboutPrivacyRedditReddit
Video library
'24
Top 4 SemisCollege

2024 NDT 24 College Semis: Michigan PD (#1) vs Emory KR (#2)

NDT 24 — Semis — Michigan PD (AFF) vs. Emory KR (NEG)

Apr 9, 20248.3k

Panel: Bricker, Gidley, Green, Hilligoss, Thur Decision: 3-2 AFF, Bricker and Hilligoss sit.

Comments

Loading comments…

1AC

Affirmative

  • Plan — eliminates nuclear bomber leg of US strategic Triad; removes wiring, signals, dual-capable mission from B-2/B-52
  • Advantage 1: First-Strike Doctrine — Air Force 'cult of the offensive' drives overconfidence in stealth, leading to forward-deployed dual-capable bombers misread by adversaries as first-strike posture; risk of inadvertent nuclear war
  • Advantage 2: Modernization/Stability — US nuclear modernization race with China/Russia; bomber modernization uniquely destabilizing because dual-use ambiguity; submarines lack same first-use doctrine
  • Internal link distinction — bombers uniquely proximate to adversary borders; subs don't carry same Air Force superiority doctrine
  • Timeframe/urgency — service timelines fragile, no margin for compromise; evidence from ~2023-24

Generated by claude-sonnet-4-6 — check it against the video before relying on it.

Related videos

DoublesKentucky·Lynbrook Debate

1AC: Ukraine Long-Range 2NR: NATO Unity DA Decision: 2-1 Aff (Reeves*, Repko, Spiers)

Ukraine Long-Range
NATO Unity DA
Oct 7, 20260.3k
DoublesKentucky·Lily Severson

3-0 for Iowa on the affirmative

Sep 28, 20261.3k

Queue

Nothing queued. Add a related video with itsbutton and it lines up here, to play when this one ends.